Show solutionHide solution
Question 1
Turn an explanation into a testable prediction
A student notices that a powdered solid disappears faster in warm water than in cool water and proposes that higher water temperature shortens the time required for complete dissolution.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Identify the observation, hypothesis, and a quantitative dependent variable.
Design a fair comparison, naming at least four controlled variables.
State a result that would challenge the hypothesis within the tested range.
Question 1 - Solution
Turn an explanation into a testable prediction
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Separate roles
The noticed difference is the observation. The proposed temperature effect is the hypothesis. Measure elapsed time from addition until a consistently defined endpoint, such as no visible grains under fixed lighting.
(b) Control the comparison
Vary temperature while keeping solid identity and mass, particle-size distribution, water volume, vessel shape, and stirring procedure fixed. Verify temperature during each trial. Randomize trial order and repeat each condition.
(c) Allow a challenge
If repeated higher-temperature trials have equal or longer dissolution times beyond the observed variability, the hypothesis is challenged over that range. A single irregular trial should trigger investigation rather than automatic rejection.
Check and interpretation
A useful hypothesis connects a manipulated variable to a measurable outcome and can disagree with data.