Chemistry: An Overview — Question 8

Section 1-1 · Chemistry pages 21–22

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

A filter result does not identify a contaminant

A clear water sample passes through an ordinary paper filter and remains clear. A dried portion of the filtrate leaves a solid residue. Assume the filter does not dissolve or shed material.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. What can you conclude about material present in the filtrate?

  2. Why did filtration not necessarily remove it?

  3. Explain why neither clarity nor the residue alone identifies the substance.

Question 8 - Solution

A filter result does not identify a contaminant

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Use the residue evidence

The filtrate contained nonvolatile material that remained when water was removed. It was not simply water that left no residue under the drying conditions.

(b) Consider the separation scale

Ordinary paper can trap sufficiently large suspended particles while allowing dissolved species to pass through with the liquid. Clear appearance is compatible with dissolved material.

(c) Avoid overidentification

Many substances can yield clear solutions and solid residues. Identifying the residue requires additional characteristic measurements or chemical tests; its appearance alone does not establish its composition.

Check and interpretation

A separation method is selective for a property or scale, not a universal purifier.