Chemistry: An Overview — Question 5

Section 1-1 · Chemistry pages 15–16

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

A material choice needs more than one attractive property

A designer compares two hypothetical bottle materials. Material A is light and transparent but deforms in hot water. Material B tolerates hot water but is heavier and opaque. The bottle must survive repeated hot-water cleaning and allow the liquid level to be seen.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why neither candidate is an unqualified solution.

  2. Propose one modification or additional design that could meet both constraints.

  3. Identify two chemical or material tests needed before approving the design.

Question 5 - Solution

A material choice needs more than one attractive property

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Apply both constraints

A fails the stated temperature requirement, while B fails the visibility requirement. Choosing only on mass or only on heat tolerance ignores a required function.

(b) Develop a testable alternative

One option is a B body with a heat-tolerant transparent viewing strip; another is a new transparent material. A proposal is a hypothesis about performance, not evidence that it works.

(c) Test relevant behavior

Test dimensional stability and leakage through repeated hot-water cycles. Also test whether the liquid or cleaning conditions alter the material or transfer material into the contents. The viewing feature must be tested as part of the assembled bottle.

Check and interpretation

The best choice depends on stated constraints and measured properties, not a single favorable label.