Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
A gas can make an open sample seem to lose matter
A reaction occurs in a cup placed on a balance. The reading falls from 125.0 g to 123.8 g while bubbles leave the liquid. Assume no liquid splashes and no material enters the cup.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the mass that left the weighed system.
Explain why this does not violate conservation of matter.
Predict the mass reading change if the entire experiment and all evolved gas were enclosed in a rigid, leak-free vessel on the balance.
Question 3 - Solution
A gas can make an open sample seem to lose matter
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Account for the loss
The loss is attributed to escaping gas under the stated assumptions.
(b) Choose the system
The cup and its contents form an open system. Matter moves from that system into the room; the cup alone is not the full material balance.
(c) Close the boundary
For a rigid, leak-free vessel with all products retained, the total mass reading should remain unchanged within measurement uncertainty. Internal redistribution does not remove matter from the weighed system.
Check and interpretation
The apparent contradiction disappears when the same system boundary is used before and after.